Suche books:   



The Civil War: A Narrative (3 Vol. Set)
Shelby Foote

Vintage, 1986

average customer review:based on 139 reviews
view larger image
 for more information click here

   highly recommended  highly recommended




Breath-taking in scope and detail

I am not a Civil War buff. In the past I've read just a couple books on the subject - one was "Killer Angels" about Gettysburg by Michael Shaara, another great book - so I decided to learn about the entire war from beginning to end. This series of books does a fantastic job of covering all the major aspects, military, civilian, political, international, etc. Foote's detailed research and true understanding of how all the pieces fit together is what, in my opinion, makes this series sing.

What I enjoyed most was seeing how the various generals moved through the ranks and became the legends we think of today. Sherman, Grant, Longstreet, Stuart, Jackson, Lee, Meade, Bragg and all the rest are here in vivid detail; some stabbing each other in the back, others showing their genius for tactics and leading men.

I laughed out loud reading about how Jeb Stuart, after his horse was struck in the neck by a bullet, stuck his finger in the bullet hole to stop the spurting blood, continued riding for a mile and then dismounted (removing his finger) and the horse collapsed. I bet it was a sight to behold!

The full breath of heroism, bad decisions and outright luck of the civil war is here to behold.

It's long, but if you enjoy to act of reading you'll enjoy every minute of this series.


 for more information click here


A classic.

I have more of a general reader's perspective on this set, as I am not a historian, nor an academic. However, I realize this is a classic; from I've gotten through so far, rightfully so.

First, this set is huge. It's taken me about two years just to get up the courage to start reading it. It's slow going, but that's because you are so enthralled in it. It is a truly great read, and I can't imagine a better narrative, nor a more descriptive one.

The only problem I have is that I wish there were more of the little graphics that show troop movements throughout the books. These really help you visualize the action more. Actually, there could probably be a whole companion book with these troop movements laid out to correspond with the chapters.

Overall though, you can't go wrong with this classic.


 for more information click here









 for more information click here


the Civil War Historians Bible

I have to say, I found one really bad thing about this book. That is, that the book had to end. This book is over 3,000 pages if you get the 3 volumn edition, and close to 3,800 if you find the 14 volumn 40th edition of it. There is nothing disparanging to say, with this book. The best Civil War historians quote this book, and like Douglas Freeman, and the O.R. it is their Bible. When I read mine, I was aware of this, and carefully used a yellow highlighter so as to be able to more easily find references, for debates, articles, and quotes.

This book does not present a Northern OR a Southern side of the Civil War. JUST FACTS, That is the true beauty of great history books.

Some people have two sets of these books, one for the office, to go over in our spare time, and another in our homes.

My warning to those that undertake to read this wonderful set of books, is don't be surprised, when you feel let down, and a little depressed, as this story has to come to an end.

As a good read, there were many pages that made me shed a tear; ( When Lincoln lay dying, and Senator Sumner was crying like a baby); to the anger at the vivid description of Shermans army burning Columbia. ( This is very descriptive, as is much of the book)

Shelby Foote painstakingly took 20 years to write this book, and did a phenomal job.


 for more information click here






A Masterpiece!

Why don't they teach American History in public schools? The Civil War was mentioned in the text books of my day, the mid-20th century, but is scarcely referred to today.
To fill this void, those who want to truly be educated must do independent reading. Having just completed the first volume of Shelby Foote's trilogy (Ft. Sumter to Perryville) I have become an avid Civil War history buff. In the past month I drove to Virginia in order to visit the Fredricksburg, Chancellorsville, and Wilderness battlefields. I anticipate I will visit others in the future.
I also discovered that the National Park Service has listings of Union and Confederate soldiers. I have been able to identify 35 Union and 8 Confederate soldiers related to me, and the regiments in which they served.
The detailed accounts of the campaigns and pitched battles in this book surpass anything else I have read about the Civil War. Shelby Foote's narratives bring the war to life.
The most surprising element I found in the book was the account of political infighting among the general officers on both sides.
The only criticism I have of the writing is that the reader sometimes finds he has been reading about the activities of a particular individual for two or three pages in which the person is always referred to as "he" and it is sometimes necessary to backtrack and see who "he" is.


 for more information click here


A Herculean effort

I was first introduced to Shelby Foote through his involvement with the Ken Burns Civil War documentary. These books are absolutely fascinating. The level of detail in his history is outstanding. One would think that the sheer bulk of these volumes would be a surefire cure for insomnia, but Mr. Foote has a refreshing style: a brilliant mix of historical fact and the storytelling smoothness of a gifted novelist. Over 10,000 books have been written about this war, and more are to come, but I believe that no one knows the war as does Shelby Foot.
A must for the serious Civil War buff (why are they always called that?).

Should he be reading this: I salute you, sir.


 for more information click here


reviews: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, page 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20



hot or not?    What's your opinion?     Write a review and share your thoughts!



recommendations

The American Civil War (1861 - 1865)
My Favorite Books on the Civil War
10,000 Pages in Six Months....
Books I Want On My Kindle
Missing the South




search for books
civil, narrative, set, war


Impressum / about us


Suche books: