A fine writer. A disappointing story.

books:


	• On Chesil Beach: A Novel Ian McEwan Nan A. Talese, 2007 - 208 pages average customer review:based on 207 reviews view larger image
	for more information click here

highly recommended

memorable book...

Romantic, thought-provoking, melancholic, heartbreaking...These are the words I would use to describe this novella...At first, it took me awhile to really "get into" this book (in fact, I would probably give it about four and a half stars, but I round up...), but once I appreciated McEwan's beautiful writing and strong characters, I fell so vividly in the book...I do have to say that at first I wanted more of a plot until I appreciated that McEwan takes a small moment and just goes with it...You'll think about this book after you put it down. (By the way, I felt that the book was not unrealistic. Florence's response/feelings may be very uncommon but not impossible.)

for more information click here

Great writing, unsatisfactory format

Author Ian McEwan has the skill of a masterful miniaturist. With exquisite delicacy, his unblinking eye and steady hand can reveal a universe illustrated by an instant in time (a single day in "Saturday", a few hours in "On Chesil Beach"). This story is, on the face of it, a simple one of wedding night panic, but behind it lurk numerous knots of emotion and experience which McEwan slowly unravels. Here is writing at its finest.
Having said that, I was disappointed with the conclusion of "On Chesil Beach". Perhaps it can be put down to a basic dissatisfaction with the novella form, but I found it all a bit too abrupt at the end. The narrative proceeds at an almost elegaic pace through a huge build-up to a crisis, and suddenly it's all over. With almost indecent haste, the last few pages "fast forward" to provide a tidy ending.
But this is a minor quibble about a couple of hours of sheer reading pleasure.

for more information click here

A fine writer. A disappointing story.

I had never read Ian McEwan's work before. I did see the film Atonement and really enjoyed it. After reading this short novel, I came away with several observations: (1) McEwan has a terrific simplistic style that invites the reader in. I was very impressed with his writing ability. (2) His description was very vivid in the telling, but not in showing me WHY for example Florence had such disdain for sex. Was it because her mother never showed her affection? Was it because something happened with her father, which was barely hinted at? It's 1962, not 1902. The setup was not believable to me. (3) When the couple finally have it out on Chesil Beach, I couldn't help but roll my eyes and state, "Give me a freakin' break!" The whole ending was not believable at all. Actually, it was preposterous, ridiculous and laughable.

In my view if a first time novelist wrote this, he or she would have a very difficult time finding a literary agent to represent the work, let alone having a publishing house publish this nonsense.

I'm giving McEwan's book 3 stars, because he is a very fine writer. If I had the opportunity to hand out stars or no stars for plot and story, I would have given this a NEGATIVE ONE.

In the future, I may read some of his earlier work in that many here seem to have high regard for it.

As to this book, I can only imagine that it's a bestseller, because of the preceding work and not because this book deserves any merit whatsoever.

for more information click here

Excellent storytellling

Anyone who has read a novel by Ian McEwan will not be surprised to discover that the language the author adopted to craft On Chesil Beach is flawless. Even as the prose urges the story forward, the reader is compelled to linger over the beautiful passages, the taut, lovely sentences and the crisp dialogue that mark McEwan as one of the master writers of our time. And, while each novel develops its own unique and curious plot, (consider the shocking end of Amsterdam or the bittersweet lesson at the heart of Atonement), each also shares a universal theme. McEwan's stories are all driven by the human desire to ponder the imponderable: "If only."

On Chesil Beach is no exception. The two main characters, Edward and Florence, are celebrating the evening of their marriage. The story begins on the night of their honeymoon, two virgins, each insecure in the knowledge of what will soon happen. Much of the novel lingers over their thoughts and anxieties, their memories and anticipation. By alternating their two perspectives, McEwan deftly captures the way our spoken words do not always accurately represent what it is we are struggling to communicate. While much of the book concerns this dance between meaning and misunderstanding, there is also action-action that has serious consequences. We glimpse the couples' past, present, and future, perfectly balanced on one moment of consummation.

Perhaps the most compelling aspect of McEwan's writing is his ability to capture the nature of time. Like Proust, McEwan can examine a single moment, filling as many pages as a description of events that have passed over a period of twenty years. It is brilliant prose that conveys a poignant, heart-wrenching love story.

Armchair Interviews says: Read McEwan for both his wonderful stories and superb storytelling.

for more information click here

reviews: 1, 2, 3, 4, page 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14

hot

not?

What's your opinion?

Write a review and share your thoughts!

recommendations

Best Books I Read in 2007 - Fiction
Best Fiction Read 2007
Best Bets from 2007
Pages 2008 II
Recent reads

search for books
on chesil beach, beach, chesil, novel

Impressum / about us