Suche books:   





Genius Denied: How to Stop Wasting Our Brightest Young Minds
Jan Davidson, Bob Davidson, ...

Simon & Schuster, 2005 - 256 pages

average customer review:based on 37 reviews
view larger image
 for more information click here

   highly recommended  highly recommended






Genius Denied: our national educational policy

Genius Denied: How to stop wasting our brightest young minds, what you and your school can do for your gifted child. The title is long, and speaks volumes. Why are we, as a country, denying our gifted children an appropriate education? What can we, as parents and as educators, do for these unique children?

What is gifted education? Genius Denied differentiates between the elitist enrichment programs billed as gifted education by school districts across the country, and real gifted education, appropriate level curriculum in major subject areas. And it asks important questions, like why is gifted education tied to the student?s age, rather than to his or her educational needs?

The gifted children hurt by our national policy of egalitarianism aren?t the rich kids, the Davidsons points out. Wealthy parents can afford the private schools, tutors, and specialized programs that gifted children need to survive and grow; they can afford to move to other school districts or states when such programs are unavailable. It?s the socio-economically disadvantaged, the immigrant, even the middle-income child who?s family cannot afford such privileges; these are the children who are denied an appropriate education.

Genius Denied is not just a story of educational failures; it details education successes, and how we can duplicate them for other gifted children. And it?s not only the gifted children, but our society as a whole that will benefit. While not every gifted child is a future inventor or political leader or composer or scientific discoverer, every gifted child IS important to the future of our nation and our world, and none should experience the educational misfortune that has been experienced by child after child detailed in the book.

Genius Denied is a book that should be read, and taken to heart, by every school administrator and policy maker, and by every parent of a gifted child. And maybe, with the help of this book, Genius Denied will become just a book title, instead of our national education policy.


 for more information click here


Highly readable, a call for change . . .

This book is wonderful, although it identifies situations in our educational systems that are certainly NOT wonderful. The authors provide individual accounts of issues faced by gifted students, as well as data regarding educational practices. The latter is supplemented by their website, www.geniusdenied.com. In detailing these situations, they don't attack the participants; they don't fragment us further by dividing us into various special interests.

Instead, this book helps every reader to understand the educational needs of gifted children and the harm that can result when those needs are not met. It inspires us to ask ourselves what we can do to help, then goes on to help us answer that question and identify positive steps that we can take.

Genius Denied is a book worth reading, whether you are a teacher, parent, community member, policy maker . . . It would be a wonderful book to hand to the parent or teacher that understands gifted children, to share the fact that others care, too. It would also be valuable to the parent or teacher who does NOT understand these children's needs, because it presents these needs in a thoughtful way that may prompt improved understanding.


 for more information click here









 for more information click here


How ironic!

How ironic! Just as I was finishing Genius Denied, I picked up the daily paper to see that the program for the "gifted children" has just been cut at the local school. As the Davidsons correctly emphasize in their book, there are priorities for all tastes and interests except the most talented students in our schools. Somehow they are supposed to adapt to the avalanche of mediocrity that surrounds them and conceal their precociousness. Sadly, and again this is a well developed theme of the book, not only are programs for gifted children underfunded, but various districts intentionally place obstacles in their path.
It is truly an interesting commentary on the state of education that 7th and 8th graders can compete with seniors in athletics, but God forbid they should skip a grade if they are superior students. They can get their skulls fractured in a sporting event, but not have knowledge put into those very same skulls.
The authors have done a masterful job of identifying and refuting many of the foolish doctrines and philosophies that have contaminated education, both public and private, for the better part of three decades: heterogeneous grouping, inclusion, mainstreaming, self-esteem prattle; all are targeted and appropriatedly consigned to the dust bin.
Genius Denied belongs on the reading docket with Diane Ravitch's - THE LANGUAGE POLICE, and Charles Syke's - DUMBING DOWN OUR KIDS. It is a desperate call for action and reform before America squanders its most precious resource - its talented youth.


 for more information click here






Essays Vs. Information

Genius Denied is a very partisan nonfiction account on how we are wasting the best minds in America. Genius Denied is written by Jan and Bob Davidson. This book starts to tell about Rachel, who as a four year old wanted to write a story about strife, but didn?t have the vocabulary to describe what she wanted to say. She was reading the Chronicles of Narnia and other fantasy books by second grade. Later she was stifled by teachers who took off points when she exceeded expectations in the length of her works. She became seriously depressed and thought of committing suicide. This story is supposed to stress the point of allowing gifted children room to grow. The whole book is many stories like Rachel?s, along with essays, research data and how to fix the problems. Genius Denied tells about the No Child Left Behind Act and the problems it causes for gifted education. The book also stresses the benefits of grade acceleration.
Genius Denied is interesting for about the first thirty pages, but by then you are looking to the bottom of the page to see if they accidentally reprinted the same page twice, no such luck. It?s hard telling Rachel apart form Barry, Nousha and all the other gifted children in this book. It?s amazing that these minds are only in the top five percent of the population as there are so many stories about them. The stories all have similar plots and only drag down the book. The book is annoyingly negative in parts, but this con is balanced by the great ways to fix the problems that they introduce. Science Olympiad and Mathcounts programs will most certainly help teachers and parents better educate gifted children, the fact that the book mentions this only can help it. Overall this book was very informative but you have to read through all the Barry?s Nousha?s first to find the actual information. However the statistics and information you do find are pure gold.
The organization of Genius Denied, was hard to follow. It didn?t appear to follow any clear distinct order, which was annoying for referencing purposes for this review. The back of the book was very well ordered however, moving through an alphabetical index, then endnotes and lastly a bibliography. The vocabulary was fairly uncomplicated, though there was the occasional educational term one might have to look up.
The authors put much of the blame on society, which in some cases is rightfully deserved. However, the writers almost seem elitist in the way they phrase it. Reading Genius Denied made me feel inferior in intellect, for the fact that I couldn?t play Mozart at two. They also made it seem as if those who are failing need less help then those that are ahead but fail to discuss the point directly. The book would have been more persuading if they had discussed the point previously mentioned.
Overall Genius Denied was an interesting read, but I wouldn?t recommend it for someone looking for a light read, don?t be fooled by the fact that it is only a two-hundred page book, it?s still a heavy read. The authors who wrote the book is the founder of the company that created Math Blaster. The book is kind of depressing, so it is an important read for those willing to recognize the inequity in our educational system.


 for more information click here


Genius Denied

The Davidsons have documented a national tragedy. They provide facts and case studies to document how our schools have become bastions of politically correct anti-intellectualism. The educational establishment devotes itself to trying to educate students who can't or won't learn, while holding back those students who can and want to learn.
Our family has been involved with the Davidson foundation for three years, and it has made an enormous difference in our lives. We have discovered that there are other children and parents who think that academic ability and achievement are not something to be ashamed of, that the educational system seems to be designed to frustrate highly gifted children, but that it can adapt itself to helping them instead.
Every parent and educator involved with gifted education should read this book. I would recommend it to gifted children also, but I expect that they will find it and read it on their own.


 for more information click here


reviews: 1, 2, 3, 4, page 5, 6, 7, 8



hot or not?    What's your opinion?     Write a review and share your thoughts!



recommendations

Education Matters! (preparing the mind to learn)
Fun and Educational Books, Games, and Toys
CESA 1 PAGE Recommended GT Books- General
Help for Gifted Children




search for books
how to stop, brightest, denied, genius, minds, stop, wasting, young


Impressum / about us


Suche books: