Suche books:   





To America: Personal Reflections of an Historian
Stephen E. Ambrose

Simon & Schuster, 2003 - 288 pages

average customer review:based on 59 reviews
view larger image
 for more information click here

   highly recommended  highly recommended





Excellent Collection of Non-Fiction Papers

My mother-in-law gave me this book as a gift. It not a title I would have selected myself, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. The rather than a single contiguous work, it is twenty essays (too formal a word) about some of the commonly held 'truths' in Modern America about issues in our history. Mr. Ambrose introduces the issue, the 'commonly' held position on modern america, then describes how he formulated his opinion as he researched different projects. The issues addressed include: The duality of Thomas Jefferson's as Author of the Declaration of Independence and a Slaveholder, Theodore Roosevelt's imperialism, Richard Nixon, Vietnam, many aspects of World War II, Race in the 1960s, and The Battle of New Orleans. The book is written in a storytellers style, which keeps it very quick paced.


 for more information click here


Flawed, but informative read, as much 'By America' as 'To America'

I bought this book not really knowing what to expect, but as an aspiring historian, I could not resist the final, personal work of one of America's greatest historians' (at $7 to boot). Providing a diverse set of passages that, though they don't always tie together very well, are a pleasure to read.

Early on, Ambrose describes various instances of American history he feels are important, defining moments. These are OK, and Ambrose often attempts to `set the record straight' on different areas from Washington (best president ever), Jefferson (hypocrite but good writer), the robber barons (ultimately good), and Teddy Roosevelt (first interventionist president and conservationist).

The middle section of the book is its weakest. Here, this is a nationalist book, albeit somewhat apologetically so, but truth be told, not really thoughtfully so. If the book had a thesis, it would be that American history (more than any other nation in the world) is about freedom at home and spreading it abroad. Nothing wrong as such, though it can be rather jarring for a non-American who also lives in a free country to read that Americans live in the "freest nation on Earth". It can also be unintentionally tragic-comical as when he writes that had Americans lost the Battle of New Orleans in 1815, the city would have been turned into "a southern version of Montreal" (not a disastrous prospect, either for the slaves living near the city then, nor given the state of city today, though Ambrose could not have a known that).

The real problem, in a book of this length, is the question of emphasis. Teddy's colonialism in the Philippines, Cuba and Panama makes way for his conservationism. As he asserts America was not imperialist post-1945, he will remind us of Ike's opposition to French Algeria but saves Truman's support for French Indochina for his chapter on Vietnam (which is, presumably unrepresentative of the general trend of US history). To prove that America was not imperialist after WW2, he cites Eisenhower's opposition to Anglo-French imperialism at Suez in 1956 but omits that same administration's role in destroying nascent democracies in the Congo and Iran. And, of course, we get reminded of America's role in creating the German and Japanese democracies again and again. (In my personal opinion, America supports democracy if and when she perceives it to be non-threatening to her interests. Which is much of the time, but not when radicals (Islamists, Communists) look ready to win, or it might deprive her of some strategic resource (Panama Canal, oil, copper, cobalt etc.).)

That is not to say Ambrose does not concede the usual sins of America's past (slavery, Jim Crow, women's rights, treatment of natives, colonialism etc,) but one feels he loves his subject too much for these to be anything more than a sideshow. The 8-page chapter on racism is about his personal experiences. Black history is for the most part limited to a few mandatory nods to MLK. That Ambrose feels the need to (albeit briefly) mention sexism, racism and imperialism says much, I think, about America. In that it is important to read. Americans wish to believe they've been exceptionally good since there founding as a nation, which poses problems when, say, a Jefferson or a Teddy is not found to be morally acceptable by today's standards. I think this is a rather American characteristic, no English historian feels morally at stake when determining whether Henry the Eighth was sexist, nor would a French historian feel the need to excuse Francis the First for not being democratic...

Ambrose's `memoir' sections are the best. The parts on the place of racism and sexism in his life are informative. His descriptions of researching and writing books are a veritable goldmine of advice and experience for any aspiring historian or even any writer. Whether it is his decade-long study of Nixon, his first written pieces as a student on obscure figures in the Civil War, his personal struggle with Vietnam or his relationships with Eisenhower and WW2 veterans (American, British and German!), I found them highly enjoyable and informative.

In all, I would not call this a great book, but it is in many places a good book. Although Ambrose fails in his ambition to show America be all that exceptional in most respects, he does succeed in sharing the sense of optimism that is characteristic of American society. And even when To America isn't particularly good, it is certainly good to read for any non-American because it seems to encapsulate America's self-perception as a force for freedom along with its self-doubt induced by the less glorious aspects of her past.


 for more information click here









 for more information click here


Great read on American history

Stephen E. Ambrose writes in a descriptive and knowledgeable, yet fun tone that continues to draw readers back to each of his compelling books. "To America" is no exception to this as it shows an interesting view on main historical happenings in the United States from foundation to present day. After reading this book I was left with many new details and actualities about our nations' history. Ambrose sheds a new light on historicalfigures such as the Founding Fathers, Nixon, Theodore Roosevelt, and Andrew Jackson. He gives details about battles so descriptive that the reader feels like they could have been there.

As I read "To America", I gained valuable knowledge that was never covered in any history class. Ambrose explains misunderstood ideas of quite a few important people, often going deeply into detail about their lives and careers. Besides obvious stories and events given about America, Ambrose also writes about his own life as an historian and author.

Anyone who reads this book will feel that they have a new set of facts about American History. With each story told, Ambrose gives the facts that are often skipped over in textbooks or lectures. Ambrose ties this book together with a powerful sense of nationalism and American spirit.

I would recommend "To America" to any reader who is looking for a new, more detailed view on U.S. History. I give it a 4 out of 5 because although it is somewhat long, any reader breezes throughwhile enjoying Ambroses confrontation of Americas successes and it failures. The reader also is able to much better understand the career of a famous and influential historian.



 for more information click here






Very dense with information

I, like many other readers/history buffs, greatly respect Ambrose for his ability to take a portion of history and give it personality and make you care.
This book is really a compilation of medium length forays into different aspects of American history. So, if you want a book that covers a wide variety of historical topics but still gives you a ton of information, pick this one up. This would be a fantastic vacation book for the history buff.
As I mentioned in the title, this book is very dense with facts and information. I had been reading for a while and was thinking about how much historical terrain I had covered. I checked the page and realized that I was only about 25 pages into the book. Luckily, Mr. Ambrose has a very personable writing style and keeps the reader interested while packing in the information. While the book is dense with information, it feels to be a very casual read.
I would recommend this book highly. These essays touch on many of the same topics Ambrose has written whole books about and give the reader a taste of the topic that may lead to further interest in the larger collection on each subject.


 for more information click here


A debt to those who went before

I have loved many of Ambrose's books, but this one really brought home to me the debt we have to those who went before. He's not afraid to say someone is not absolutely perfect (i.e. Jefferson) or absolutely evil (i.e. Nixon). But what he does show is that the American way, with a sense of right and wrong, has prevailed up to the end of the 20th Century, and by implication, that sense of right and wrong need to be there for us to continue into the 21st Century.

Thank you, Mr. Ambrose, for this goodbye card to America.


reviews: page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10



Completed shortly before Ambrose's untimely death, To America is a very personal look at our nation's history through the eyes of one of the twentieth century's most influential historians.

Ambrose roams the country's history, praising the men and women who made it exceptional. He considers Jefferson and Washington, who were progressive thinkers (while living a contradiction as slaveholders), and celebrates Lincoln and Roosevelt. He recounts Andrew Jackson's stunning defeat of a superior British force in the battle of New Orleans with a

ragtag army in the War of 1812. He brings to life Lewis and Clark's grueling journey across the wilderness and the building of the railroad that joined the nation coast to coast. Taking swings at political correctness, as well as his own early biases, Ambrose grapples with the country's historic sins of racism; its ill treatment of Native Americans; and its tragic errors such as the war in Vietnam, which he ardently opposed. He contrasts the modern presidencies of Eisenhower, Kennedy, Nixon, and Johnson. He considers women's and civil rights, immigration, philanthropy, and nation building. Most powerfully, in this final volume, Ambrose offers an accolade to the historian's mighty calling.




 for more information click here



hot or not?    What's your opinion?     Write a review and share your thoughts!



recommendations

to understand our world - past, present and future
Philosophy, Poli-Sci and a Little History
Alex's Summer Reading List
Great History Reads
Military History




reflections

Reflections in Bullough's Pond: Economy and Ecosystem in New England ...
The Funhouse Mirror: Reflections on Prison
A Joseph Campbell Companion: Reflections on the Art of Living
A Charlotte Mason Companion: Personal Reflections on the Gentle Art ...
Chicken Soup for the Woman's Soul: 101 Stories to Open the Hearts and ...



historian

A People's History of American Empire
Night Train to Memphis
Historians' Fallacies : Toward a Logic of Historical Thought
Angle of Repose (Penguin Twentieth-Century Classics)
Laughter of Dead Kings (Vicky Bliss, No. 6)



personal

The Success Principles(TM): How to Get from Where You Are to Where ...
The Care & Keeping of You: The Body Book for Girls (American Girl ...
Rocket Boys (The Coalwood Series #1)
Prophet (Arkana)
Lost Boy



search for books
america, historian, personal, reflections


Impressum / about us


Suche books: