I recommend this book for anyone concerned with the environment.

books:


	• Predatory Bureaucracy: The Extermination of Wolves And the Transformation of the West Michael J. Robinson University Press of Colorado, 2005 - 473 pages average customer review:based on 3 reviews view larger image
	for more information click here

Thorough - - but loses the forest for the trees

This book is a highly-regarded study of the extermination of wolves in the US West over the last century. Unfortunately, I'm unable to give it as high a rating as the other reviewers. Certainly Robinson knows his material and he has given us an exhaustive story of how the Bureau of Biological Survey (BBS) and other agencies exterminated the wolf.

Unfortunately, the narrative is not only exhaustive but exhausting. Robinson has given us too much, and culled too little, to make for a compelling story. The basic structure is clear enough: cattlemen cleared out bison and put cattle in their place on the open range; wolves found cattle (and sheep) easy prey; cattlemen and other settlers organized to eliminate wolves; a scientific agency in the federal government found an opportunity to grow powerful by providing the service of wolf extermination to a wide constituency instead of doing science for a narrow constituency; and even after eliminating wolves, the BBS moved to kill other species, which it continues to do today (under a different name). Thanks to its political allies, the BBS resisted all attempts to rein it in, though the Endangered Species Act has slowed it down.

That could have been a six-chapter story. One might have expanded it to perhaps twelve chapters, to allow for changes in the players and their actions over time. Unfortunately, Robinson gives us 27 chapters. We meet a lot of individuals, whether scientists, politicians, stockmen, administrators, bounty hunters, or wolves. But Robinson tries too hard to be thorough, so we meet too many of these characters.

I realize that professional historians generally value this kind of definitive treatment of a subject, and this book certainly provides a definitive history of the wolf extermination program. More implicitly than explicitly, it raises serious questions about the complicity of government in despoiling the environment instead of protecting it. Robinson's analysis of the political support coalition behind a very destructive agency could lead any earnest young environmentalist to despair.

Even admitting all that, the book would have been better had it been shorter.

for more information click here

I recommend this book for anyone concerned with the environment.

I recommend this book for anyone concerned with the environment and the effect of government policies on the environment. It is an impressive, well-written scholarly work. It traces national and local policies toward (against) wolves from the mid-19th century to the present. The research is thorough and extensive. It demonstrates a profound understanding of the relationship between government and land-owners and the implications of policies for the ecology of the Western U.S. It includes an unprecedented detailed count of the wolves, coyotes, and livestock killed since 1878. The writing is beautiful. For example, on page 4, Robinson writes: "In fall the crisp weather turned aspen leaves yellow, and the first wisps of snow wafted in like unhurried emissaries from a season the hard, cold ground had never quite forgotten." This is a ground-breaking work.

Pearl Katz, Ph.D.
Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine

for more information click here

HOWLING TO THE CHOIR:

Wolves in the West from Rout to Reintroduction
by Wayne Sheldrake, Author of "Instant Karma: the Heart and Soul of a Ski Bum"
It takes a little romance to feel a kinship with wolves, but to become involved in the process of their protection and reintroduction one has to be practical. Michael Robinson, an avowed wolf activist is a practical romantic. Predatory Bureaucracy: The Extermination of Wolves and the Transformation of the West keeps the wilderness poetics to a minimum and lets the history, legislation and law of extinction speak for itself.
In a story that is part tragedy and part epic, the power of his tale lies in the character and flaws, of wolves and men. The enemies of wolves, trappers and hunters motivated by bounties or salaries, are portrayed as outdoorsmen of perseverance and skill, men who often admired their enemies even as they killed them. Wolves, though decidedly disadvantaged and obviously doomed, are remembered as insightful and tough (undeniably killers too). The heroes among them knew the individual scent and habits of their human torturers.
From Robinson's long perspective, the true villain of extermination was the triumvirate of environmental holocaust, federal bureaucracy and poison. The quick demise of the buffalo caused wolves serious problems. Abandoned carcasses were an irresistible boon and wolves proliferated. (29) When the free range--literally free: no grazing fees, no fences, no railroads, yet--was repopulated with cattle, wolves did what wolves do. Stockgrowers associations offered bounties, pressing counties and states to do the same. (30-31) But hunters and trappers went where bounties were highest, and they let pups mature until they were worth money. (64) Wolves bounced back, until a system emerged that compensated for the limitations of commercial cooperation, local government, and human nature.
In 1905, the new Forest Service "enacted" grazing fees. Cattleman immediately demanded protection from wolves. (51) About that time, the federal Bureau of Biological Survey was looking for ways to fund scientific projects. (63) They saw they could provide a service by quashing criticism that the FS provided wolves sanctuary, (78) and offering stockmen--very influential constituents of Congress (53)--"a more centralized system" of efficiently poisoning "`noxious animals'." (66) Robinson gives the Biological Survey a face, Stanley P. Young, master-trapper turned Uber-bureaucrat. Young cast wolves as "criminals." (155) He presented slide shows on poisoning to annual stockgrowers meetings and conventions. (155) He solicited annual contributions to the agency from states, counties and "local ranching associations." (164) He reported successes: 25 wolves killed in 1921 (153); 19 dead in 1922. (157) He also contended with little or no opposition. (Robinson includes an interesting chapter that explains the inaction of women's organizations, the American Bison Society, Aldo Leopold and Enos Mills.) When the wolves were gone, he deftly shifted the blame and the bureaucracy flourished, killing coyotes.
Here the book embarks on a complex and innervating odyssey. A new kind of hero, and, paradoxically, a new kind of bureaucracy emerge. Into the late Twenties, conservationists complained internally that the loss of wolves was a loss to science; and predators, they had observed, helped prevent the spread of disease among ungulates and rodents, and controlled populations. (181-182) Young responded by cleansing agency terminology. "Extermination" became "control." (198) In 1930, 148 scientists signed a letter protesting widespread poisoning. (212) F.D.R. tried to cut the BS budget in '31. (257) Congress reversed the cuts. (260) He appointed a critic as Chief. Poisoning continued. (264-268) By 1945, the agency had a new name, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and had adopted new poisons (coyotes spit out strychnine) and aerial gunning. (297) These were seminal years in the development of the practice (and personality!) of conservation activists.
Rosalie Barrow Edge, a lifetime member of the Audubon Society, was "appalled" when she learned the Society turned its head from the BS's poisoning of magpies (246) because the birds ate coyote baits. (169-177) She filed "what may have been the first private citizen environmental lawsuit," and won. (247) William Hornaday, who had fought to save the last bison, shared his mailing list (249), and she helped found the Emergency Conservation Committee, which supported the formation of wilderness, the "removal of all livestock from National Forests," (249) and "indicted `wholesale poisoning and trapping operations'." (250) The committees mass mailings were written by scientists.
Times and minds changed. The scientific work of mammologists like Joseph Grinell and his student E. Raymond Hall came to bear. Aldo Leopold, a former wolf killer, connected the preservation of predators to the preservation of land. (298) Even the founder of the BS "[came] out against the poisoning program." (251) Finally, Stuart Udall became Secretary of the Interior and Rachel Carson's Silent Spring aroused public concern over the impact of poisoning on humans in the early sixties. Still, the institution of poisoning wasn't collared until Nixon banned it in 1972. The ban was disarmed by Ford, Carter and Reagan (327, 329), but by then the Endangered Species Act was law. Though it didn't forbid poisoning per se, it outlawed "any action that would doom a listed species, including destroying its habitat." (323) The Act also gave citizens the right to sue for failure to enforce and mandated reintroduction. In 1986, when the EPA tried to "reauthorize...strychnine for rodent control" Defenders of Wildlife and the Sierra Club sued. (330)
Robinson spends the remainder of the book recounting wolf reintroduction based on the tradition of legal activism and concessions. Wolves were returned to Idaho, Yellowstone and the Southwest amidst the opposition of equally active western ranchers. In Yellowstone, Defenders of Wildlife "promised to reimburse ranchers for the cost of livestock killed or injured by wolves." (341) and wolves "known to be preying livestock" were shot from "planes and helicopter." Still, by 2005, "over 900 wolves roamed Wyoming, Idaho, and Montana," and a few wandered to Washington, Oregon, Utah, and Colorado. (346) Reintroduction in the Southwest was bitter, violent and disappointing. Over three years, the population remained static at 27 wolves. (363)
Robinson's polemic against bureaucracy is strong. The history of the BS as a policy-maker operating as a service at the beck and call of a powerful political constituency puzzles together the zeitgeist, backroom politics, and scientific exchange of the times through the remarkably frank letters and memos of the principals. There's less voice, and less depth to more recent personalities, when the research relies primarily on published statements, news reports, and legal briefs.
The writing is most compelling in the early history of the west, when the individual character of wolves--their heroic escapes, their family loyalties, their tragic ends--packs the narrative with drama and grief. Hunters are masterfully juxtaposed as men whom, though diabolically skilled, possessed wild, near-meditative wolf-wit. Trapping wolves was so difficult (and dangerous to livestock) that poisons came to the fore, but even poisoning a wolf took insight that a naturalist would envy.
Robinson's captive audience, wolf lovers, will be rapt with the epic martyrdom of a species, and they may be agitated to tactical, practical action. Reintroduction opponents might be moved to reexamine the grim history of a bureaucracy that exceeded the viciousness of its prey.

for more information click here

Predatory Bureaucracy is the definitive history of America?s wolves and our policies toward predators. Tracking wolves from Coronado?s day to the present, author Michael Robinson shows that their story merges with that of the U.S. Bureau of Biological Survey. This federal agency was chartered to research insects and birds but?because of various pressures?-morphed into a political powerhouse operating wildlife--extermination programs.

Drawing on deep research and wide reading, Robinson's vivid narrative follows the wolves from the eras of explorers, mountain men, and bounty hunters through the wolves' 120-year entanglement with the federal government. He shares the parallel story of the Survey's rise, detailing the personal and political forces that allowed extermination programs to continue?despite opposition from hunters, animal lovers, scientists, environmentalists, and presidents?though the agency's mission and even its name changed several times. Federal predator control nearly eliminated wolves throughout the United States and Mexico and radically changed American lands and wildlife populations.

The story Michael Robinson tells in Predatory Bureaucracy will fascinate readers interested in wildlife, nature, agriculture, and environmental politics.

for more information click here

hot or not? What's your opinion? Write a review and share your thoughts!

recommendations

on Bureaucracy
Animals Matter

transformation

The Social Transformation of American Medicine
The Great Transformation: The Beginning of Our Religious Traditions
The Great Transformation
The Black Death and the Transformation of the West (European History ...
The West: Encounters & Transformations, Atlas Edition, Volume 1 (to ...

predatory

Why Are So Many Black Men in Prison? A Comprehensive Account of How ...
Monster of God: The Man-Eating Predator in the Jungles of History and ...
Where the Wild Things Were: Life, Death, and Ecological Wreckage in a ...
Predatory Game (GhostWalkers, Book 6)
The Father's Emergency Guide to Divorce-Custody Battle: A Tour ...

west

The Strongest Tribe: War, Politics, and the Endgame in Iraq
A Long Way Gone: Memoirs of a Boy Soldier
Into the Wild
The Glass Castle: A Memoir
Black's Law Dictionary, Eighth Edition (Black's Law Dictionary ...

search for books
bureaucracy, extermination, predatory, transformation, west, wolves

Impressum / about us