A review of Catwoman: When in Rome

books:

	• Catwoman: When in Rome (Batman) Jeph Loeb DC Comics, 2007 - 160 pages average customer review:based on 16 reviews view larger image
	for more information click here

highly recommended

Saving the best for last

When we last saw Catwoman at the end of Dark Victory, we had learned of the possibility that Carmine Falcone was her father. In this followup, the last of Jeph Loeb's very successful trilogy that started with The Long Halloween, we find Selina in Rome searching for the answers to this mystery. Accompanying her on this roller coaster journey is one Mr. Edward Nigma, aka The Riddler, who ably and humorously provides the fodder for Selina's many acid tongued barbs, and as we eventually find out later in the story, much, much more. From the intriguing plotline to the witty one-liners and Selina's insightful and engaging internal monologue, this tale fires on all cylinders. Loeb's love for Catwoman is obvious, with his extensive use of her in all of his Battales, and who can blame him. Her star power shines brightly throughout them all by the sheer force of her multifaceted and magnetic personality. Loeb delivers, for a delightful change, a fairly wordy script that isn't the rapid read that his two previous installments of this ongoing saga, especially TLH, were and in the process delivers his most exceptional work yet. Most sequels usually end up as pale and disappointing imitations of the original, but he has bucked that trend with this series that exhibited improvements with each installment, culminating here with his grand finale. His place in the Batman pantheon of writers was cemented with these books, and while he may be currently writing for Marvel, here is one fan who would like to see him weave his magic one more time with the Bat and the Cat.

for more information click here

Ok...Just Ok

This book is ok and would otherwise be horrible if it wasn't for the ever beautiful artwork of Tim Sale thus making all my reviews of his books to have a minimum rating of three stars if the story is horrible like this one. Selina whose secretly Catwoman is a moody lady (very realistic) and quite dreamy. There is a reason for this as she battles her moods and dreams to uncover the truth of her past, specifically the identity of her parents. However, this is not a Catwoman origin story as some people say since it does not explain how or why she became Catwoman. Selina is pretty sexy in this book, but it does not really make up for poor story or lack of real villains in this story.

for more information click here

Loeb and Sale do it again

Loeb is one of our greatest comic book writers,especially when it comes to Batman. He'skinda making our hero into something new, much more believable. Loeb and Sale's classic story (where their reputation rests) is the early Batman stories, like The Long Halloween, which features Catwoman quite prominently, though she does disappear. This is the story of her time gone from TLH, in Rome. We learn a lot about Selina Kyle. It seems Loeb's influence is heavily on her as well as many of the other Batman characters.

A review of Catwoman: When in Rome

This is a bookend (or rather a filler?) to Loeb and Sale's The Long Halloween and Dark Victory. When Catwoman disappears partway through Dark Victory, she goes to Rome to do some "research." She is accompanied by The Riddler, and receives assistance from an Italian hitman known as The Blonde (guess why?). While there, she discovers that other DC villains may have followed along. Catwoman is also linked to the murder of a Don and gets to steal from the Vatican... which should be on every tourist's list of things to do while in Italy.

I liked this book, but I have a bias towards Catwoman. And the artwork is excellent, though not in the same style as Long Halloween/Dark Victory. The story is so-so. We all know what Selina/Catwoman is in Rome to find out, but it's still treated like a mystery, and it certainly didn't have the drawing power of figuring out who was the Holiday murderer. I also never found the Riddler as ominous as some other reviewers have said... mostly, I just thought he was pervy.

So the final verdict is... if you like Catwoman and/or really enjoyed Loeb and Sale's other Batman stuff, you'll probably enjoy this. It works as a stand-alone, but I didn't think it was a must-read.

for more information click here

Purrrrfect!

Loeb, Sale, and Selina Kyle. What a dynamic trio. This is a great story about a little trip that Selina takes with the Riddler, of all people, to Italy, and the fun and mayhem that she causes there. I may be biased, because I am a huge Catwoman fan and I think this is the best story ever written. Plus, you put the words of Loeb with the artwork of Sale together and you just can't go wrong. I recommend this to anyone who loves either Catwoman, Loeb and Sale, or just an excellent story all around.
Peace and Love,
Jake

reviews: page 1, 2, 3, 4

The acclaimed, Eisner award-winning team of writer Jeph Loeb and artist Tim Sale return to Gotham City, home of Catwoman, for a tale that takes the Feline Fatale into a dangerous new realm.

WHEN IN ROME chronicles Catwoman's mysterious trip to Italy and her dealings with the deadly Falcone crime family. It's a colorful tale of Gotham's sexiest cat burglar at her most intriguing.

for more information click here

hot or not? What's your opinion? Write a review and share your thoughts!

recommendations

The Totally Incomplete List of Every Jeph Loeb Comic
The Definitive Batman Collection
What the gun read in 2008
D.C. Comic Universe
Batman

batman

All-Star Batman & Robin, The Boy Wonder, Vol. 1
Batman: Dark Victory
Batman: The Long Halloween
Batman: Year One
Batman: The Killing Joke

when

What to Expect When You're Expecting: 4th Edition
When Genius Failed: The Rise and Fall of Long-Term Capital Management
When Markets Collide: Investment Strategies for the Age of Global ...
When Bad Things Happen to Good People
When Technology Fails (Revised & Expanded): A Manual for ...

rome

12 Caesars : The Twelve Caesars
Mark of the Lion : A Voice in the Wind, An Echo in the Darkness, As ...
A Voice in the Wind (Mark of the Lion #1)
The Golden Ass: The Transformations of Lucius
The Complete Roman Army

search for books
when in rome, batman, catwoman, rome, when

Impressum / about us