Suche books:   





Them: A Novel
Nathan McCall

Atria, 2007 - 352 pages

average customer review:based on 21 reviews
view larger image
 for more information click here

   highly recommended  highly recommended





Incites hot discussion. Good first novel, Nathan.

Nathan McCall graciously attended a Literary Police book club meeting in March. The conversation was intense. You'll understand why when you read Them, the author's first novel after his much celebrated, Makes Me Wanna Hollar.
The main character, Barlow Reed is an angry dude. Mad at everything and everybody. When a white couple moves next door to him this sets his ire in a whole new direction. I won't go into the whole story as it's already detailed in other reviews. What I would have rather seen in the book is a relationship between the two male characters (Barlow and Sandy's husband). I think this would have really been more dynamic. I never felt there was a connection between Barlow and Sandy and their coming together didn't ring true for me. There was never any reason for either of them to take interest in the other, but yet here they are each day talking over a fence. Other than that, I truly enjoyed the story and look forward to reading this author's next work.


 for more information click here


Them

With its corner store, house of ill-repute, and elder residents, the Old Fourth Ward is home to many characters - some crooked, some straight - and in the middle is Barlowe Reed - the hard-working, short-tempered, trying to get himself together type of brother.

As this community of mostly Black residents begins to change and more of "them" move in, one of "them" (Sean and Sandy Gilmore) moves next door to Barlowe. While Barlowe develops a civil relationship with the female neighbor across the fence, his relationships with his Black neighbors become strained. Tensions begin to mount as the Old Fourth Ward becomes the neighborhood of "us" versus "them" as "they" seek to make changes in a place that doesn't feel "their" kind of change is necessary.

This book started off with a bang, but by the time I got to Part 3, it fizzled. I had grown tired of reading. I can't explain why as I thought the story was good, albeit predictable, and a nice change in reading material for me. The main characters (Barlowe and Sandy) and secondary characters (Tyrone and Sean) were interesting and developed - but stereotypical to some degree. You really kinda knew what they were going to do/say. I don't know why I didn't like this book more, however, I'd recommend this if you're tired of reading relationship fluff and want something with a little more meat on its bones. 3.5 stars!


 for more information click here









 for more information click here


(RAW Rating: 4.5) - Caesar

THEM by Nathan McCall features Barlow Reed as a 40-something African-American man living in the Old Fourth Ward in Atlanta. As gentrification takes hold in his neighborhood, Barlow and his neighbors become suspicious and resentful of the new inhabitants and changes they are attempting to make.
The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language list the following definition for gentrification: The restoration and upgrading of deteriorated urban property by middle-class or affluent people, often resulting in displacement of lower-income people.

Barlow is employed by a local printing press, has a troubled nephew living with him and a girlfriend, who literally does Barlow a favor by breaking things off with him. Barlow, a simple guy, works, reads, plays the lottery and hates all forms of government, thus nicknaming it "Caesar". When neighbors, Sandy and Sean, move next door and restore the old house inside and out, Barlow is forced into action of doing the same to his home, but first he must purchase it. Sandy and Sean must examine their reasons for wanting to relocate from suburban Atlanta to the Old Fourth Ward. Are they trying to send a message or is it something more innocent and noble?

At times, THEM is a dramatic read with highlights of humor. The situations of fear and fear of the unknown play well, but eventually veer off to being over-the-top and stereotypical. There are the gatherings of the locals and new inhabitants to establish neighborhood ground rules, which lead to gatherings of the black locals who try to relive the glory days of the civil rights movement. There are also confrontations both vocal and physical. The sociological and psychological messages are plenty and THEM is sure to cause much debate and discussion around the practice of gentrification.

Reviewed by Dawn R. Reeves
of The RAWSISTAZ Reviewers



 for more information click here






Too many stereotypes spoils the broth

McCall's autobiography, Makes Me Wanna Holler, was superb. And the topic of urban gentrification is timely and ripe for fictional exploration. So I was eagerly anticipating this book. Unfortunately, I was not able to suspend my disbelief. Both the protagonist, African American renter Barlowe Reed, and his nemesis, white homeowner and next-door neighbor Sandy Gilmore, are unconvincing. Some critics thought it was just the white characters who were two dimensional, but I found even the black characters (such as Reed's parolee nephew Tyrone) to be wooden stereotypes. Perhaps it's because I live on the West Coast, and in the San Francisco Bay Area, but it's hard for me to believe that either African Americans or whites at the dawn of the 21th century in a big city like Atlanta could be as naïve and inexperienced with other races as these folks are. And while white people are most definitely dense and clueless at times, Sandy's husband Sean is an over-the-top caricature of weak white masculinity. McCall makes some good points about cultural misunderstandings and how they can escalate into warfare as the privileged classes inexorably push out the less affluent old-timers, but in striving to make his point we lose some of the complexities and subtleties of real-life urban enclaves in transition. Although I did get a kick out of Barlowe's visceral antipathy toward "Caesar" and the U.S. flag (you have to read the book to get this), overall I was hoping for something deeper or more profound.


 for more information click here


The Old Fourth Ward

"Them" is McCall's first foray into fiction and he has done an outstanding job of character development for I visualized them, admired some, ranted at others and wanted to smack a few. After completing the book last week, I actually found myself driving down Auburn Avenue, cutting up Hilliard and Boulevard just feeling the lives of the people in McCall's story AND of the oldsters & newcomers who actually do live in the Old Fourth Ward now--the old neighborhood where MLK Jr. grew up.


reviews: page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5



The author of the bestselling memoir Makes Me Wanna Holler presents a profound debut novel -- in the tradition of Tom Wolfe's Bonfire of the Vanities and Zadie Smith's White Teeth -- that captures the dynamics of class and race in today's urban integrated communities.

Nathan McCall's novel, Them, tells a compelling story set in a downtown Atlanta neighborhood known for its main street, Auburn Avenue, which once was regarded as the "richest Negro street in the world."

The story centers around Barlowe Reed, a single, forty-something African American who rents a ramshackle house on Randolph Street, just a stone's throw from the historic birth home of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Barlowe, who works as a printer, otherwise passes the time reading and hanging out with other men at the corner store. He shares his home and loner existence with a streetwise, twentysomething nephew who is struggling to get his troubled life back on track.

When Sean and Sandy Gilmore, a young white couple, move in next door, Barlowe and Sandy develop a reluctant, complex friendship as they hold probing -- often frustrating -- conversations over the backyard fence.

Members of both households, and their neighbors as well, try to go about their business, tending to their homes and jobs. However, fear and suspicion build -- and clashes ensue -- with each passing day, as more and more new whites move in and make changes and once familiar people and places disappear.

Using a blend of superbly developed characters in a story that captures the essence of this country's struggles with the unsettling realities of gentrification, McCall has produced a truly great American novel.


 for more information click here



hot or not?    What's your opinion?     Write a review and share your thoughts!



recommendations

A Whole Bunch of Marvelous Fiction
Some Magnetic Fiction
Pumped-Up Fiction
Urban Books
Good Books




novel

The Story of Edgar Sawtelle: A Novel
Batman: The Killing Joke
Loving Frank: A Novel
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
A Thousand Splendid Suns



search for books
a novel novel, novel, them


Impressum / about us


Suche books: