Suche books:   





Culture and Conflict in the Middle East
Philip Carl Salzman

Humanity Books, 2008 - 224 pages

average customer review:based on 5 reviews
view larger image
 for more information click here

   highly recommended  highly recommended





Rich explanation of Arab Tribalism

Watch out for the negative reviews that are bound to be posted by multiculturalists.

This book is a powerful, lucidly written and unique contribution to the discussion which brings an ethnographers eye and work to the question of tribalism and its link to Arab political corruption and lack of social progress. Far from a damning ciritcism of Arab culuture Salzam elucidates the brilliance of the tribal dynamic of balanced opposition in reducing violence and granting the strength of group idnetity. For Salzman the problem arises when that same dynamic is so structurally pervasive that it inhibits a society's ability to adhere to abtsract principles such as rule of law and maintenance of individual rights.

Some will accuse Salzman, very unfairly and inaccurately, of being a western triumphalist, trust me, such people are simply outraged that his objectivity has led to critical judgments. His section on the myth of an Islamic tolerant golden age is particularly necessary in light of the usual drivel on the topic.

Salzman's work is part of a growing body of correction to the vision of Edward Said and an all the more important one as it comes from an anthropologist/ethnographer perspective.

Salzman's writing exhibits commendable brevity and clarity considering the nature of the subject.


 for more information click here


Tribalism: the unacknowledged soverign.

This book explains in vivid detail the totally different world view of a tribal society when contrasted with those with which we in the west are familiar. The political relationships in the Middle East must be understood in the context of that environment, which is tribal. We cannot look at the muslims of the middle east and think they are 'just like us' because they are not. The societies and cultures of the Middle East and the West are, literally, centuries apart. This book explains why, and leads us to recognize that any interation with the ME must take into account these profound differences. A 'must read' for anyone wanting to understand the gravest threat to our way of life.


 for more information click here









 for more information click here


100% Accurate

Dr. Salzman has hit a home run with this book. I have spent a number of years in the Middle East and have dealt with virtually every segment of the population there, from nomads to farmers to businessmen to politicians, engineers, doctors, women, soldiers, and even insurgents. What I saw while I was there coincides completely with the information contained in this work. Not only does he draw from personal experience, Dr. Salzman also pulls from expert research in the field of Middle Eastern Studies to weave a masterpiece.

Be advised: Dr. Salzman does not pull his punches regarding the shortcomings of Middle Eastern culture. While much of what he writes may be difficult for some to swallow, it is true. Other reviewers may fault him for not conducting a similar review of Western culture, but please note the title; this is a survey of Middle Eastern culture, not Western culture or even culture in general. There are many similarities among cultures across the world, but each culture stresses certain qualities and attributes differently, and Dr. Salzman's expertise in the field of Middle Eastern culture enables him to make an excellent analysis of its particular strengths and weaknesses. Those who take issue with his work will do so along emotional lines because his writing is not "polite" or flattering. When any culture is exposed to the harsh light of educated analysis, the warts will show; Middle Eastern culture is no different from any other in that respect.

In conclusion, for any potential reader, I would like to make this comment. If Dr. Salzman had published this work in 2001, and every American and Allied officer had been required to read this before the invasion of Iraq, the current Iraqi conflict would have ended 3-4 years ago. This book is that accurate, powerful, and insightful. Everyone who has any contact with the Middle East should read it, or ignore it at their own peril.


 for more information click here






absolutely eye-opening

Stanley Kurtz is right about this book. It is a must read for all those desirous of understanding and fighting against Islamic jihadism.



In an era of increasing interaction between the United States and the countries of the Middle East, it has become ever more important for Americans to understand the social forces that shape Middle Eastern cultures. Based on years of his own field research and the ethnographic reports of other scholars, anthropologist Philip Carl Salzman presents an incisive analysis of Middle Eastern culture that goes a long way toward explaining the gulf between Western and Middle Eastern cultural perspectives

Salzman focuses on two basic principles of tribal organization that have become central principles of Middle Eastern life--balanced opposition (each group of whatever size and scope is opposed by a group of equal size and scope) and affiliation solidarity (always support those closer against those more distant). On the positive side, these pervasive structural principles support a decentralized social and political system based upon individual independence, autonomy, liberty, equality, and responsibility. But on the negative side, Salzman notes a pattern of contingent partisan loyalties, which results in an inbred orientation favoring particularism: an attitude of my tribe against the other tribe, my ethnic group against the different ethnic group, my religious community against another religious community. For each affiliation, there is always an enemy.

Salzman argues that the particularism of Middle Eastern culture precludes universalism, rule of law, and constitutionalism, which all involve the measuring of actions against general criteria, irrespective of the affiliation of the particular actors. The result of this relentless partisan framework of thought has been the apparently unending conflict, both internal and external, that characterizes the modern Middle East.


 for more information click here



hot or not?    What's your opinion?     Write a review and share your thoughts!





conflict

Understanding International Conflicts (6th Edition) (Longman Classics ...
Coward's Guide to Conflict: Empowering Solutions for Those Who Would ...
Supreme Conflict: The Inside Story of the Struggle for Control of the ...
Short Stories: Characters in Conflict
Currie, Kay, Kramer and Roosevelt's Conflict of Laws: Cases and ...



east

Three Cups of Tea: One Man's Mission to Fight Terrorism and Build ...
No True Glory: A Frontline Account of the Battle for Fallujah
Thunder Run: The Armored Strike to Capture Baghdad
The Last Stand of the Tin Can Sailors: The Extraordinary World War II ...
From Baghdad, With Love: A Marine, the War, and a Dog Named Lava ...



search for books
culture and, conflict, culture, east, middle


Impressum / about us


Suche books: