A Very Garry Wills Version of Religion in America.

books:


	• Head and Heart: American Christianities Garry Wills Penguin Press HC, The, 2007 - 640 pages average customer review:based on 12 reviews view larger image
	for more information click here

highly recommended

Poor Jesus

This is an excellent, intelligent survey of Christianity in America and farther back where necessary. There's a lot of material here, but the things I liked best were the emphasis on the wisdom of separating church and state, and the difference between Christianities based on emotion and based on intellect. This is a theme with great potential. Each approach seems insufficient by itself but the emotional assault on heaven is the way most liable to disaster. And we see numerous instances of emotionally insistent stupidities. Nazism, after all, was a form of religion. Emotionally charged tribalism: we see it over and over, and inevitably it obligates people to kill one another. It's a strong force, much stronger than reason, but...

I hadn't known what the evangelists who are going to "leave behind" the rest of us were all about, so I was glad to learn about them. In fact, you will gather a great deal of interesting information from this book, if you are sufficiently detached. Obviously, the evangelistically convinced are not going to be persuaded by an appeal of reason and a study of evangelical history, since they already know everything that needs to be known, very like the people that killed themselves to get on the flying saucers. So you wonder, Can a book really help enlighten the benighted? And really no one, not even Wills, has sorted out the emotional energy that makes us convinced in our convictions, the unassailable pride we have in our opinions. Atheist, Christian, whatever, it's the unexamined belief in one's own supremacy that presents the greatest problem.

Nevertheless, this is a noble effort, a contribution to the hope that civilization can actually happen. Excellent book.

for more information click here

A Very Garry Wills Version of Religion in America.

This book is not a history of religion in America--it is Garry Wills' commentary on both the history of American religion, the various historical studies of American religion and the current situation. So for those who are looking for a straightforward and balanced history of religion in American, look elsewhere. That said, I must say that I enjoyed reading it Wills is a very engaging writer and his basic argument--when religion and politics gets too close, religion is the loser--makes sense. His comments on the current situation are very instructive. It would be interesting to see what he has to say about the position of other non-Judeo-Christian religions in America such as Islam and Buddhism. I think the 21st century is going to see a remaking of the map of religion in America

for more information click here

Head and Heart: American Christianites

An insightful and excellent read. A must read for those interested in religion and theology.

Varieties of Christian Experience in America!

Christianity in America is as varied as it is fervent, as diverse as it is constant. In Head and Heart, Gary Wills gives us a rich, thorough, and at many (not all) points celebratory history of Christian pluralism in America. Throughout his historical survey, Wills points out that American Christianities can be divided into two basic groups: "head" religions, which look towards the rational side of things, and "heart" religion, which focuses on the emotional side of religious experience. American Christian history, Wills intimates, may be best viewed as the interplay between these two "styles."

The first group we encounter, colonial Puritanism is a "heart" religion, focusing more on religious emotion and supernaturalism than rationalism. We then turn to the American founding, where "head" religions like deism were at a high. Emphasis was on "natural theology" - human attempt to experience God through reason rather than revelation. Wills then takes us through the first and second "great awakenings," the advent of Fundamentalism and Dispensationalism, ("heart" religions all), through post-war Progressivism ("head" religion), up to the very present resurgence of Fudanmentalism. All the while, Wills is a master story teller: as thorough as he is engaging.

While Wills is respectful to all of his subjects (with the exception of the current Rove-driven "religious right"), he will score few points with right-leaning readers. Section 2 ("Enlightened Religion") makes much of the idea that while many founders were religious, their primary reliigion was a deism that was unitarian and tended to reject much of the Bible, making it hard to see ours as a nation founded on fervent Christianity. As already mentioned, the final section of the book ("Religious Nation") takes a lamenting tone when talking about current state of religious influence in American politics and the Bush Adminstration.

Through all, though, Wills stresses the necessity of a constant push-and-pull between "head" and "heart" religions. "The point, for purposes of this book, is that the populist pole of religiosity needs interaction with the elitist pole" (from the chapter "Evangelicals Brough Low," p. 422). The former group, tending towards the "heart" side, keeps religion alive and vibrant, while the latter, "head" oriented group keeps religion within rational bounds. Leave the one unchecked, and you either strip religion of its heart or mind. The picture Wills paints serves to remind us that religion functions best when there is a delicate balance between "head and heart."

for more information click here

reviews: page 1, 2, 3

A landmark examination of Christianity's place in American life across the broad sweep of this country's history, from the Puritans to the presidential administration of George W. Bush. The struggle within American Christianity, Garry Wills argues, now and throughout our country's history, is between the head and the heart: between reason and emotion, Enlightenment and Evangelism. Why has this been so? How has the tension between the two poles played out, and with what consequences, over the past 400 years? How "Christian" is America, after all? Garry Wills brings a lifetime's worth of thought about these questions to bear on a magnificent historical reckoning that offers much needed perspective on some of the most contentious issues of our time. A religious revolution occurred in America in the 18th century, one that saw the emergence of an Enlightenment religious culture whose hallmarks were tolerance for other faiths and a belief that religion was a matter best divorced from political institutions-the proverbial "separation of church and state." Wills shows us just how incredibly radical a departure this separation was: there was simply no precedent for it. To put this leap in perspective, Wills provides a grounding in the pre-Enlightenment religion that preceded it, beginning with the early Puritans. He then provides a thrillingly clear unpacking of the steps, particularly Madison's and Jefferson's, by which church-state separation was enshrined in the Constitution, and reveals the great irony of the efforts of today's Religious Right to blur the lines between the two. In fact, it is precisely that separation that has allowed religion in America to flourish since the disestablishment of religion created a free market, as it were, and competition for souls led to the profusion of denominations across the length and breadth of the land. As Wills examines the key movements and personalities that have transformed America's religious landscape, we see again and again the same pattern emerge: a cooling of popular religious fervor followed by a grassroots explosion in evangelical activity, generally at a time of great social transformation and anxiety. But such forces inevitably go too far, provoking a backlash as is happening right now with the forces of Creationism and the anti-abortion fundamentalists. Garry Wills closes with a penetrating dissection of the Religious Right's current machinations and the threat they pose to the enlightened religion that has proved to be such a fertile and enduring force throughout American history. But in the end, Wills's abiding message is to be vigilant against the triumph of emotions over reason, but to know that the tension between the two is in fact necessary, inevitable, and unending.

for more information click here

hot