Suche books:   





Plan of Attack
Bob Woodward

Simon & Schuster, 2004 - 480 pages

average customer review:based on 253 reviews
view larger image
 for more information click here

   highly recommended  highly recommended





Good Information

Bob Woodward's follow up to "Bush at War", "Plan of Attack" is a big improvement from the previous book. Woodward, a mainstay in political circles was privy to an amazing amount of information through interviews, memo's, manuscripts, presentations and transcripts. It is this access that allows the reader into the discussions, maneuvering, and planning of the pre-emptive strike against Iraq.

"Plan of Attack" opens two (2) months after 9/11 when Bush instructed Rumsfield to develop a new war plan for Iraq, and the book brings the reader along for the ride as the players move towards the inevitable. The book is reasonably balanced and provides enough ammunition for the "anti-Iraq war" and the "pro-Iraq war" segments. Both sides able to use this book to further promote their views becasue the key players knew how to use Woodward to promote their objectives.

It was interesting to see evidence that the Iraq war was pre-ordained when Cheney already had it as a priority before Bush's inauguration. However, it was also interesting to see that Bush was not Cheney's puppet as some would believe. Bush made some decisions early on in the strategizing that moved the country towards war even before the administration knew their decision: "Axis of Evil" speech, Iraq intelligence gathering that ignited mobilization of the Iraq people, and the Saudi Arabia agenda are some examples. Although some of Bush's early mistakes helped force our hand into war, he also clearly thought he was doing right thing with no hidden agendas. Regardless of the flawed intelligence, Bush believed he was making the world a more peaceful place through democracy in Iraq.

The personality and policy clashes (Tenet's manipulation, Powell's contradiction between opposing the war and selling it, Franks always the loyal soldier but disdain for Rumsfeld's team and their demands, Cheney opposing Powell's suggested approaches) was very interesting. Other gems within the book are: the full court press in selling this war to America and other nations, the CIA's intelligence effort, Saudi Arabia's influence and the ineffectiveness at the UN.

Very well done.



 for more information click here


Deju vu all over again

I just reread _Plan of Attack_, and was struck by how much light it sheds on the currently unfolding drama swirling around Iran.

To the extent that President Bush still appears to believe that it is his sacred duty to strike pre-emptively at evil wherever he finds it, then the current "coercive diplomacy" being aimed at Iran--the current exemplar of his "axis of evil"--seems likely to end in war, just as it did in Iraq.

The parallels between the developments that Woodward reports on in the run-up to the war in Iraq, and what we are seeing with respect to Iran, are eerie--the distortion and exaggeration of intelligence to justify the war, the simultaneous building up of forces in the region, and the willingness to shift justifications as needed, jump from the page.

At this moment, December of 2007, when we are learning that our own intelligence does not support the existence of a nuclear threat from Iran, we're also seeing the neocon establishment attack the messengers, and re-focus on Iran's intent rather than capability. Unless Bush and those around him have experienced a real change of heart, the White House depicted by Woodward can be expected to redouble its efforts to bring about regime change in Iran, rather than admit any errors and change course.

I strongly recommend giving _Plan of Attack_ a read or re-read right now, certainly for what it says about how and why we got into Iraq, but even more for what it may presage about Iran.


 for more information click here









 for more information click here


Woodward gets more royalties for his access

Woodward seems to have a little industry of churning these books out (and other people doing a lot of the work).

This book shares the faults and good points of the earlier book: basically a recounting of a lot of meetings that we were never in...but still a limited picture of what people were REALLY thinking...and no analysis of what they SHOULD have been thinking.

Somehow it seems just a bit richer and more interesting than the previous one. As if either the events were more intriguing or Woodward had warmed to his subject more. But still...too much of a reportorial data dump.


 for more information click here






Wrong Voice

Very well-written and informative book, but the person "reading" the book had a somewhat monotone voice. Really detracted from it. Worth reading -but not worth buying the book on tape.


reviews: page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10



Plan of Attack is the definitive account of how and why President George W. Bush, his war council, and allies launched a preemptive attack to topple Saddam Hussein and occupy Iraq. Bob Woodward's latest landmark account of Washington decision making provides an original, authoritative narrative of behind-the-scenes maneuvering over two years, examining the causes and consequences of the most controversial war since Vietnam.

Based on interviews with 75 key participants and more than three and a half hours of exclusive interviews with President Bush, Plan of Attack is part presidential history charting the decisions made during 16 critical months; part military history revealing precise details and the evolution of the Top Secret war planning under the restricted codeword Polo Step; and part a harrowing spy story as the CIA dispatches a covert paramilitary team into northern Iraq six months before the start of the war. This team recruited 87 Iraqi spies designated with the cryptonym DB/ROCKSTARS, one of whom turned over the personnel files of all 6,000 men in Saddam Hussein's personal security organization.

What emerges are astonishingly intimate portraits: President Bush in war cabinet meetings in the White House Situation Room and the Oval Office, and in private conversation; Dick Cheney, the focused and driven vice president; Colin Powell, the conflicted and cautious secretary of state; Donald Rumsfeld, the controlling war technocrat; George Tenet, the activist CIA director; Tommy Franks, the profane and demanding general; Condoleezza Rice, the ever-present referee and national security adviser; Karl Rove, the hands-on political strategist; other key members of the White House staff and congressional leadership; and foreign leaders ranging from British Prime Minister Blair to Russian President Putin.

Plan of Attack provides new details on the intelligence assessments of Iraq's alleged weapons of mass destruction and the planning for the war's aftermath.


 for more information click here



hot or not?    What's your opinion?     Write a review and share your thoughts!





attack

The Attack
Love Attack Volume 3 (Love Attack)
Panic Attacks Workbook: A Guided Program for Beating the Panic Trick
Attack Politics: Negativity in Presidential Campaigns Since 1960 ...
When Panic Attacks: The New, Drug-Free Anxiety Therapy That Can ...



plan

Master Plan of Evangelism, The
Plan B 3.0: Mobilizing to Save Civilization, Third Edition
Business Plans Kit For Dummies (For Dummies (Business & Personal ...
Nursing Care Plans: Nursing Diagnosis and Intervention (Nursing Care ...
Manual of Psychiatric Nursing Care Plans (Varcarolis, Manual of ...



search for books
plan of attack, attack, plan


Impressum / about us


Suche books: